The Best MLB Players of All Time: Reddit Users Share Their Favorites

Find out who Reddit users consider their favorite MLB players of all time!

Reddit users recently shared their favorite MLB players during their lifetime. Let’s see who made the list!

Summary

  • Discover who Reddit users consider their favorite MLB players
  • Maddux’s comment sparks a humorous discussion
  • The inclusion of David Eckstein intrigues some users
  • General consensus is that it’s a good list

Maddux’s Humorous Remark

Reddit user whyamiwatchingnews injected humor with Maddux’s comment on Tony Gwynn, stirring laughter among commenters. It added a light-hearted tone to the discussion.

David Eckstein’s Surprising Presence

User Soviet_Plays brought up the unexpected mention of David Eckstein, especially in an MLB the Show context. The choice raised eyebrows and curiosity among readers.

The General Consensus

Despite differing opinions on individual players, user c_0h commended the overall compilation. The positive feedback indicated a shared appreciation for the list.

Questioning David Eckstein

User ThejewelersJeweler expressed surprise at David Eckstein’s inclusion, showcasing how the list prompted users to reconsider their favorite players.

Overall, the Reddit post sparked entertaining discussions and insights into users’ personal preferences, highlighting the diverse and humorous nature of sports fandom.