In a heated discussion about WHIP in baseball, fans debate whether the stat should include HBP, citing tradition and simplicity.
Summary
- WHIP simplicity vs. complexity debate
- HBP’s impact on WHIP numbers analyzed
- Suggestions for alternative stats like OPS against
- Preference for using BR/9 as a more comprehensive stat
WHIP Tradition vs. Change
In the discourse, fans argue that WHIP’s simplicity is its strength, resisting the inclusion of HBP to maintain tradition.
HBP Impact Assessment
Some fans believe that adding HBP to WHIP would make minimal changes while others oppose it for diluting the stat’s original purpose.
Alternative Stats Consideration
Discussion extends to proposing OPS against as a replacement for WHIP, suggesting a shift towards more comprehensive metrics.
BR/9 Preference
Supporters of incorporating HBP advocate for using BR/9 as a preferred stat that combines WHIP and HBP for a more detailed analysis.