A fisherman is puzzled after hooking an unknown fish. Reddit users weigh in passionately on the possible species, from tarpon scales to grass carp.
Summary
- Users speculate the mystery fish could be a tarpon scale or a grass carp, while some suggest a gar or carp.
- Enthusiasts offer differing opinions on the fish’s identity based on the scale structure and environment clues.
- The debate highlights the diverse experiences and knowledge of the fishing community.
Tarpon Scale or Grass Carp?
A user, OthyR, believes the scale resembles a tarpon scale, drawing from personal experience. RatherBeFeeshing disagrees, suggesting a grass carp due to its behavior near the surface and snagging tendencies.
Gar or Carp?
Shroggy3456 leans towards a gar identification, whereas booziwan keeps an open mind, considering big scales as a factor. Liucius playfully adds a simple yet accurate suggestion – a fish.
The diverse interpretations of the mystery fish showcase the engaging nature of fishing discussions. Each opinion contributes unique insights, adding to the excitement of uncovering the fish’s true identity.