Fans on Reddit are split on the recent format change for the Home Run Derby, with some criticizing the new rules and others proposing nostalgic alternatives.
Summary
- Fans express frustration over the frequent rule changes in the Home Run Derby.
- Suggestions are made to revert to older formats with innings and outs.
- Some fans criticize the presentation and production quality of the event.
- Alternative ideas like using pitching machines are proposed for a fair competition.
Fans’ Frustrations
One user expressed, “Makes sense, they gotta change the rules every other year cause after 40 years they still can’t figure out how to do something so simple.” This sentiment reflects a common frustration among fans who feel the constant rule changes are unnecessary.
Nostalgic Alternatives
Another user suggested, “Use a pitching machine instead of whomever else is throwing them meatballs. That way they’re all on an equal playing field and not limited to ‘my personally curated pitcher just wasn’t grooving enough meatball pitches through my wheelhouse’.” This idea resonates with fans longing for a more fair and traditional approach to the event.
Criticism of Presentation
One fan criticized, “They don’t even have camera angles that can show the flight of the ball. The whole presentation has become a total disgrace. The rules are not the problem.” This critique highlights fans’ concerns about the visual quality and overall presentation of the Home Run Derby.
The recent format change for the Home Run Derby has sparked a lively debate among fans, with opinions divided on the direction the event should take. While some express frustration over the constant rule changes and production quality, others propose nostalgic alternatives and fairer competition methods. It seems the future of the Home Run Derby remains up in the air, with fans eagerly awaiting what changes may come next.