Are players selected for the All-Star game solely based on popularity?
Summary
- Should player selection for the All-Star game focus only on stats?
- Fans acknowledge the game has always been a popularity contest.
- Some fans believe the selections align with what most fans want to see.
- One user humorously labels it as a ‘first half of the season popularity contest.’
Debates on Popularity
Many users point out that the All-Star game has long been driven by player popularity rather than just skills or stats. ‘Bro you fan from under a rock? Been a popularity contest for decades. Stans vote,’ one comment reads.
Fans’ Perspective
While some fans agree that popularity plays a significant role in All-Star selections, others argue that a balance is necessary. ‘If these are the guys most fans wanna see, I’m not sure I see the problem. There are always some misses, but, generally, the fans do ok,’ a user states.
Evolving Contests
Users humorously acknowledge the longstanding trend, with one replying, ‘Lmfao…..you act like this is new. It’s always been that.’ The debate on the nature of player selections for the All-Star game continues among fans.